I Get Emotional About Life – Week 1

This week’s chapters were literally all I asked for. While reading, my mind was occupied with questions all the time. I had a feeling that cultural psychology was going to be fun but I had no idea it was going to be mindblowing and addicting. Throughout the week I couldn’t stop thinking about everything from a cultural perspective, which I learned quickly, should be the standard (?). Maybe not in my everyday life but at least in my academic life. The skills and confidence I gained just from reading 2 chapters from a handbook is unbelievable.

My Questions

Although I take a lot of notes as I read, I took regular breaks just to collect my thoughts and questions on the paper reading these two chapters. At first, I felt a bit slow and under-educated about the topic, but that feeling quickly went away as I understood that I was just very really interested. While the second chapter was relatively harder to ask questions and add comments because it was about the history of the field, I wrote down a total of 39 questions for the first one. Here are some of my questions, some I consider relevant and some just fun to think about:

  • Can influencers be “culture ambassadors” because they do have the power to (maybe) create or at least contribute to and spread  “ideas, values, attitudes, mindsets, schemas, and stereotypes”? And just how much power do they have?
    • Are what we call “xyz aesthetic” just microcultures? (e.g. the recent “tradwife aesthetic” with more conservative values, the “clean girl aesthetic”, or “y2k”?
  • Can culture be a way of collective thinking – if I was an alien completely unknowing of “culture” as a concept, would I think humans with the same cultures were telepathic?
  • Just how much are we motivated by creating and trying to apply our own culture in our social realm?
  • So if psychology considers “guiding what the individual should be doing and how to be a person” one of the most important functions of cultures, what relationship does culture have with personality disorders, or any mental illness at all, as their symptoms may include inability to orient their life and loss of individuality?
    • How much of a problem does not “belonging or fitting in” cause in mental illnesses from a cultural perspective?
  • Can we talk about a culture of anything? E.g. the culture of this one coffee shop I go to, the culture of being an iPhone user, or the culture of having glasses instead of contact lenses, or the culture of a friend group, or a family?
    • Is personality an individual culture – made up of several different microcultures?
  • If your occupation makes you adopt a more independent or interdependent view of self or behavior, and some of the core values recruiters looking for like “multi-tasking” or even “team player”  can be associated with either one of these perspectives; how much do recruiters consider cultural influences in the workplace, can or should they assess a culture for a specific workplace and recruit accordingly?
  • From a cultural perspective, is saying someone is “anormal”, or even “weird” just a rude way of saying we don’t understand their culture?

Thoughts & Feelings

As this was a week of introduction, I found the chapters very successful in teasing the concepts I’m sure have more depth to them. Overall, it was very enjoyable to think about culture as an invitation. I had great satisfaction from my perspective changing from culture being a separate entity from the individual, to the individual being a part of it. It was almost annoying to try to understand different types of cultural mechanisms, like trying to think of myself as an independent person. I just couldn’t get myself to think like that! Still, I am convinced that everyone is multicultural and intersectional – and it is complicated. This was great motivation not only for the other courses I am taking, but even for thinking of new defense mechanisms for my personal life, and trying to bring other perspectives of how I view myself and others.


Comments

5 responses to “I Get Emotional About Life – Week 1”

  1. lutfiye berjin bozdag Avatar
    lutfiye berjin bozdag

    In general, I found your questions quite interesting and fun to think about, some of them very contemporary. There were even some questions that I envied, wondering why I hadn’t thought of them. Also, like you, I had a hard time trying to think of myself as independent and at times I got frustrated. I wanted to answer a few of the most interesting questions (for myself of course) from my perspective.
    You made a very good point, especially with the question about influencers. Influencers influence culture and society sometimes even more than politicians. Considering this huge sphere of influence, I think it would not be wrong to define them as “cultural ambassadors”. But considering that they are also influenced by culture… I think we can all be cultural ambassadors. I would also consider “aesthetics”, which takes up a lot of space in social media today, as microculture.
    I also agree with the idea that collective thinking is part of culture, but I don’t think you would be living independently of culture even if you were an unaware alien, I don’t think any living being can be separated from this concept.
    Another question that interested me was the one you linked mental illness and culture. I’m sure culture plays a very important role. For example, did you know that there is a phobia only Asian men experience that their genital organs will go inside their bodies and then they will die?

    1. Refik TA Avatar
      Refik TA

      Thank you for your contribution to the text. Answering the questions raised is a good way to react. However, you could also consider giving recommendations to help your friend improve how she writes reactions. Is there anything you’d like to add or how would you structure the text differently?

    2. buse zehra celik Avatar
      buse zehra celik

      Hi Berjin, sorry for the late reply as I wasn’t aware that we could reply at all. Regarding your kind words, I really appreciate the time you took to answer my questions. I’m also very glad to see that we think alike. Looking forward to discuss more about this with you (especially the alien part)!

  2. Refik TA Avatar
    Refik TA

    Hi, this is the first blog post for the Culture and Psychology course. It’s nice to see this! I’d like to mention a few points:

    * It seems like you have updated the interface of your blog yet, which I really liked that you already personalized it.

    For the text:
    – Generally, I really liked the way you are expressing both emotions, and thoughts you had during the readings. Also having a lot of questions is great while learning a new topic. Maybe you might also add your answers at least some of the questions you raised. In that way, we could see how the chapters/ readings effected you in answering the questions. Then you may take another look at your answers after the class discussion if you are thinking in a different way.
    – You have a structure already, but as another way you could try structuring the text in a different way—like having a short intro to what you’ll talk about, then the main body/ Q&A, and a brief closing that sums up what you’ve shared.
    Thank you your efforts and looking forward to reading the next ones!

    1. buse zehra celik Avatar
      buse zehra celik

      Hi hocam, thanks for the encouraging feedback. I’ll take them into serious consideration.

Leave a Reply to buse zehra celik Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *